Current:Home > FinanceNYC bans unusual practice of forcing tenants to pay real estate brokers hired by landlords -Wealth Impact Academy
NYC bans unusual practice of forcing tenants to pay real estate brokers hired by landlords
View
Date:2025-04-17 10:43:04
NEW YORK (AP) — Mandatory broker fees, an unusual feature of New York City apartment hunting long reviled by renters, will be banned under legislation that passed Wednesday after overcoming fierce backlash from the city’s real estate lobby.
Under a system that exists in New York and almost nowhere else in the country, tenants are often forced to pay the commission of a real estate agent before moving into an apartment, even if that agent was hired by the landlord.
The fees are steep, typically totaling as much as 15% of the annual rent, about $7,000 for the average-priced New York City apartment.
The legislation passed by the City Council aims to stop landlords from saddling tenants with those payments — at least as an up-front fee. Though tenants may hire their own representatives, they will no longer be forced to pay for brokers that solely represent the interests of their landlords.
In a city where two-thirds of households are renters, the bill is widely popular, a rare piece of municipal legislation championed by influencers on TikTok. It has also triggered opposition from brokers and their representatives, who warn it could send shockwaves through an industry that employs 25,000 agents.
“They spent hundreds of thousands of dollars to lobby our politicians to try to kill this bill and try to force you to pay broker fees,” Councilmember Chi Ossé, a Democrat who sponsored the the FARE Act, said at a rally Wednesday. “But you know what we did: We beat them.”
New York’s broker fee arrangement dates back nearly a century to a time when agents played an active role in publishing listings in newspapers and working directly with would-be tenants. The commission structure is also found in Boston, but few other parts of the country.
But with most listings now published online, and virtual or self-guided tours gaining popularity since the COVID-19 pandemic, many New Yorkers have grown increasingly frustrated by the fees.
At a City Council hearing this summer, multiple speakers recalled shelling out thousands of dollars to a broker who seemed to do little more than open a door or text them the code to a lockbox.
“In most businesses, the person who hires the person pays the person,” Agustina Velez, a house cleaner from Queens, said at that hearing. She recalled paying $6,000 to switch apartments. “Enough with these injustices. Landlords have to pay for the services they use.”
Brokers counter that they do much more than merely holding open doors: conducting background checks, juggling viewings and streamlining communication with landlords in a city where many tenants never meet the owners of their buildings.
“This is the start of a top-down, government-controlled housing system,” said Jordan Silver, a broker with the firm Brown Harris Stevens. “The language is so incredibly vague, we actually have no idea what this would look like in the world.”
Others opposed to the bill, including the Real Estate Board of New York, say landlords will bake the added costs into monthly rents.
But some New Yorkers say that would be preferable to the current system of high up-front costs that make it hard to move.
“From the perspective of a tech investor and business owner in New York City, the more we can do to make it cheaper and easier for talented young people to come here and stay here, the better off we’ll be,” entrepreneur and bill supporter Bradley Tusk said in a statement. “Anyone who has paid 15% of their annual rent in brokers fees for someone to let you in an apartment for 10 minutes knows the practice is nothing more than legalized theft.”
Mayor Eric Adams, himself a former real estate broker, has raised concerns about the legislation and possible unintended consequences.
“Sometimes our ideas are not fleshed out enough to know what are the full long-term ramifications,” he said this week, adding that he would work “to find some middle ground.”
But he will have limited leverage in doing so: The legislation passed by a vote of 42 to 8, a veto-proof margin. It takes effect in six months.
veryGood! (88169)
Related
- Paula Abdul settles lawsuit with former 'So You Think You Can Dance' co
- Cam Taylor-Britt dismisses talent of Chiefs' Xavier Worthy: 'Speed. That's about it'
- Disney superfan dies after running Disneyland half marathon on triple-digit day
- Kelly Clarkson Reacts to Carrie Underwood Becoming American Idol Judge
- Selena Gomez's "Weird Uncles" Steve Martin and Martin Short React to Her Engagement
- American Airlines flight attendants ratify contract that ends their threats to go on strike
- Colorado mayor, police respond to Trump's claims that Venezuelan gang is 'taking over'
- Ex-Massachusetts lawmaker convicted of scamming pandemic unemployment funds
- The Grammy nominee you need to hear: Esperanza Spalding
- Meet the cast of 'The Summit': 16 contestants climbing New Zealand mountains for $1 million
Ranking
- Selena Gomez engaged to Benny Blanco after 1 year together: 'Forever begins now'
- An 8-year-old boy who ran away from school is found dead in a neighborhood pond
- US consumer sentiment ticks higher for second month but remains subdued
- Kelly Clarkson Reacts to Carrie Underwood Becoming American Idol Judge
- 'As foretold in the prophecy': Elon Musk and internet react as Tesla stock hits $420 all
- Nikki Garcia Seeks Legal and Physical Custody of Son Matteo Amid Artem Chigvintsev Divorce
- Norfolk Southern Alan Shaw axed as CEO after inappropriate employee relationship revealed
- Congressional Democrats push resolution that says hospitals must provide emergency abortions
Recommendation
Kylie Jenner Shows Off Sweet Notes From Nieces Dream Kardashian & Chicago West
Studies on pigeon-guided missiles, swimming abilities of dead fish among Ig Nobles winners
Jack Antonoff Has Pitch Perfect Response to Rumor He Put in Earplugs During Katy Perry’s VMAs Performance
Former employee of troubled Wisconsin prison pleads guilty to smuggling contraband into the prison
Small twin
Tech companies commit to fighting harmful AI sexual imagery by curbing nudity from datasets
Cam Taylor-Britt dismisses talent of Chiefs' Xavier Worthy: 'Speed. That's about it'
Fight to restore Black voters’ strength could dismantle Florida’s Fair Districts Amendment